More than 5,000 Seattle pizza lovers have spoken: The first round of our reader-voted Seattle Times Pizza Smackdown is over, with our initial field of 32 pizzerias sliced in half! Check out an updated bracket above, and read on for a recap of results from Round 1 — as well as reactions from our food team, and some stats breaking down the opening round. Stay tuned: Next week, we’ll launch Round 2 of voting! In the meantime, give us your hottest Seattle pizza takes: Who got robbed? Which pizzeria do you have going all the way? Sound off in the comments! Winning pizzerias in bold. Percentages reflect share of head-to-head vote.
No. 1 Stevie’s Famous (62.4%) vs.
No. 32 Proletariat Pizza (37.6%) No.
2 Pagliacci (55.9%) vs. No.
31 Via Tribunali (44.1%) No. 3 Veraci Pizza (45.
9%) vs. No. 30 Hot Mama’s (54.
1%) No. 4 Zeeks (49.5%) vs .
No. 29 Ananas (50.5%) No.
5 Delancey (68.9%) vs. No.
28 Cornuto (31.1%) No. 6 Moto (58.
8%) vs. No. 27 Dino’s (41.
2%) No. 7 Windy City Pie (67.1%) vs.
No. 26 West of Chicago Pizza Company (32.9%) No.
8 Tivoli (63.9%) vs. No.
25 Slice Box (36.1%) No. 9 Sunny Hill (58.
7%) vs. No. 23 Olympia Pizza (41.
3%) No. 10 Lupo (42.1%) vs.
No. 24 Post Alley Pizza (57.9%) No.
11 Mioposto (62.6%) vs. No.
22 Independent Pizzeria (37.4%) No. 12 Big Mario’s (61.
1%) vs. No. 21 Rocco’s (38.
9%) No. 13 Jackson Street Pizza Lounge (30.5%) vs.
No. 20 Cornelly (69.5%) No.
14 Strega Pizzeria (31.7%) vs. No.
19 Bar del Corso (68.3%) No. 15 Dantini (36.
7%) vs. No. 18 T.