Kris Jenner's heartfelt birthday tribute to her granddaughter Penelope Disick was met with skepticism as a commenter questioned the authenticity of her sentiments. Penelope celebrated her 12th birthday on Monday, July 8, and Kris honored the occasion with a touching Instagram post featuring a montage of Penelope's photos through the years. Kourtney Kardashian's daughter slams dad Scott Disick's inappropriate dating age Scott Disick admits he’s a 'laughingstock' following drastic weight loss "Happy birthday to my beautiful Granddaughter, Penelope! Watching you grow into the smart, kind, funny, creative, amazing young lady you are today has been one of my greatest joys.
I am so proud of you, P!" Kris wrote early Monday. She continued: "You are such an amazing sister, daughter, granddaughter, friend, cousin and niece. You light up every room with your smile and fill our hearts with so much love.
"May your day be filled with joy, laughter, and all your favorite things. I love you to the moon and back! Lovey xo #HappyBirthdayPenelope. " View this post on Instagram A post shared by Kris Jenner (@krisjenner) Despite the warm wishes, a fan raised an eyebrow at the repetitive nature of Kris's messages over the years, commenting: "Has anyone noticed she writes the same thing every year?" Another chimed in, suggesting that Kris might not even pen her own tributes: "She kinda writes the same thing to almost all her family members.
Or maybe hires a writer." Another remarked on the lack .
